Costs

Relief Milkers or a Permanent Overseas Farm Assistant? What Irish Dairy Farmers Pay for Milking Cover Versus a Work Permit Hire

Updated 20 November 2026  ·  6 min read  ·  By Monette, Founder of CA Recruitment

The Short Answer

Relief milking suits a smaller herd that needs a few milkings a week covered. A permanent dairy farm assistant on a work permit suits a herd that needs full-time help all year. Teagasc draws the line by herd size: below 160 cows, part-time help such as relief milking; over 200 cows, full-time help.

The two costs also run differently. Teagasc's figures price relief cover by the number of milkings done. A permanent assistant on a permit is paid a salary, and the permit has one-off costs of its own.

This post covers that comparison only. Whether the role qualifies, the pay floor in detail, the 50:50 rule and the quota position are in our guide to hiring dairy farm assistants from overseas.

Correct as of 20 November 2026. The permit salary floor rises in stages under DETE's roadmap, and dairy permits have closed once already when an earlier quota filled. Get in touch and we will check the current position for your farm before you spend anything on the process.

Why Dairy Farms Lean on Relief Milkers

The farmer runs out of hours. Teagasc says dairy farmers work, on average, 60 hours a week excluding breaks, and take just 14 full days off a year.

Teagasc calls relief milking a proven option where a herd needs part-time help. It also points to a benefit that is easy to miss: someone who milks for you regularly knows your farm and your parlour, so there is a person to call on if you are sick.

What Relief Milking Costs

A Teagasc article from March 2026 sets out an example. Around €10,000 of wages, at eight rows of cows, gets around 150 to 200 milkings done. Seven milkings a week, or 300 a year, comes to around €15,000 plus 9% PRSI.

Its table shows what each level of spend buys back:

Treat those as worked examples, not a rate card. Teagasc's figures assume eight rows of cows. Our advice: take the real figure from your own records for the last twelve months, calving months included.

What a Permanent Farm Assistant Costs

Pay has a legal floor. A dairy farm assistant on a General Employment Permit must earn at least €36,605 a year, based on a 39-hour week. That is basic pay only. Bonuses, shift allowances and overtime do not count towards it. Our dairy hiring guide explains the floor in full.

The all-in figure is higher. Teagasc puts a full-time employee, including taxes, at nearly €45,000. At €1,000 profit a cow, it says, that is 45 cows' worth of profit paying for the help.

The one-off costs come before the first milking:

Section 55 of the Employment Permits Act 2024 bars you from deducting permit, recruitment or travel costs you paid from the worker's wages, or recovering them any other way. Those costs are yours. Our full cost guide sets out the rest.

Which One Fits Your Herd

Start with Teagasc's herd-size figures. Herds below 160 cows are paying circa €150 to €200 per cow in wages, which is part-time help. Herds over 200 cows need full-time help, at €300 to €400 per cow. For a herd in the part-time band, Teagasc calls relief milking a proven and effective option. A permanent hire there may cost more than it saves.

Then do the sum for your own farm:

  1. Relief side. Add up twelve months of relief milking, and note how many hours of milking it covered.
  2. Permanent side. Take the assistant's salary, or Teagasc's all-in figure of nearly €45,000, and add the one-off permit costs above.
  3. Compare the hours as well as the money. Teagasc's €15,000 example buys 600 hours. The permit salary floor is calculated on 39 hours a week for 52 weeks, which is 2,028 hours.

If you are already paying €20,000 or more for relief cover and still working 60-hour weeks, the permanent hire is worth costing properly. If relief milking gives you two days off a week and the bill is closer to €10,000, it may still be the better answer.

One risk to price in: a General Employment Permit holder can change employer once nine months have passed since they started their first permit job in Ireland. Our advice: count that risk when you compare the two. Fair hours and a decent place to live give a worker reasons to stay.

Decide Before Calving, Not During It

Here relief cover wins outright. A permit hire takes months. The job has to be advertised for 28 days before you can apply, and DETE needs the application at least 12 weeks before the start date.

Our advice: make the decision the summer before calving, not in January. Keep your relief milker booked for the first calving season either way, and count that cost in your sums until the new assistant's first milking.

How CA Recruitment Helps

Tell us your herd size, your calving dates and what relief cover cost you last year. We will run the comparison with you and say plainly if relief milking is still the cheaper answer for your farm. Where a permanent dairy farm assistant makes sense, we source the worker and manage the permit from the advert to arrival. See our agriculture recruitment page and our overseas farm worker service, or book a free consultation.

Frequently asked questions

Teagasc gives an example of around €10,000 of wages for 150 to 200 milkings, and around €15,000 plus employer PRSI for seven milkings a week, or 300 a year. Teagasc's figures assume eight rows of cows, so use your own pay records for the real figure on your farm.

For a smaller herd, usually yes. Teagasc says herds below 160 cows pay circa €150 to €200 per cow in wages for part-time help, and that relief milking is a proven option at that size. Herds over 200 cows need full-time help, at €300 to €400 per cow. Teagasc puts a full-time employee, including taxes, at nearly €45,000.

€36,605 a year, based on a 39-hour week. That is basic pay only: bonuses, shift allowances and overtime do not count towards it.

Several months. The job has to be advertised for 28 days before you apply, and DETE needs the application at least 12 weeks before the start date. Keep your relief milker until the new assistant's first milking.