The Short Answer
Agency drivers suit the days you cannot predict: sickness, holidays, a short peak. A permanent driver on a work permit suits the seat you fill with agency week after week. If one of your trucks has had an agency driver in it most weeks this year, cost a permanent hire against twelve months of those invoices. If you book agency for a few weeks around Christmas, the sum may not favour the permanent hire.
The difference is how the cost runs. Agency cover is a charge that keeps coming while the seat stays empty. A permit hire has one-off costs at the start, then a salary.
This post covers that cost comparison only. Which drivers qualify for a permit, the licence condition and the permit process are in our guide to hiring HGV drivers from overseas.
Correct as of 19 November 2026. The permit salary floor rises in stages under DETE's roadmap. Get in touch and we will check the current position for your drivers before you spend anything on the process.
What Agency Driver Cover Really Costs You
Start with your own agency invoices. A rate card will not tell you what your depot actually paid last March.
Before you read those invoices, know what the rate has to cover. Under the Protection of Employees (Temporary Agency Work) Act 2012, an agency worker must get equal treatment with workers the hirer employs directly on pay, overtime, night work and public holidays. An agency driver in your cab has to be paid at least what you would pay your own driver for the same work.
Then pull the invoices:
- Take twelve months, not three. If some months are busier than others, a short window will either flatter or overstate what agency costs you.
- Split by seat. Separate the days that covered a real vacancy from the days that covered holidays and sickness. Only the first group is what a permanent hire would replace.
- Split by licence. The permit route for drivers is built around CE and C1E licences, so compare like with like.
Some costs never show on the invoice. An agency driver may not know your routes, your customers' delivery windows or your trucks, and the driver can change from one week to the next. Those costs are real. Park them, and get the cash comparison right first.
What a Permanent Permit Driver Costs
Pay has a legal floor. An HGV driver on a General Employment Permit must earn at least €36,605 a year. DETE converts that over a 39-hour week, a working year of 2,028 hours, which comes to about €18.05 an hour. Only basic salary and health insurance payments count towards it. Our advice: pay the floor in basic salary and treat overtime and night-out money as extra.
The one-off costs come before the first run:
- The DETE fee. €1,000 for a General Employment Permit from 6 months up to 24 months. If DETE refuses the application, 90% is refunded.
- The Labour Market Needs Test. The vacancy runs with the JobsIreland/EURES service and on one other online platform, each for at least 28 continuous days.
- Your recruitment fee, if an agency sources the driver and manages the permit.
Section 55 of the Employment Permits Act 2024 bars you from deducting permit, recruitment or travel costs you paid from the driver's wages, or recovering them any other way. Those costs are yours. Our full cost guide sets out the rest.
Comparing a Year of Each
A permanent driver is paid in February as well as December. That is the real difference from agency cover, which you pay only when you book it. So compare a year, not a week:
- Agency side. Add up twelve months of agency invoices for the vacant seat, from the split above.
- Permanent side. Take the driver's annual salary, add whatever else each employee costs you on top of pay, then add the one-off costs.
- Subtract. If the agency total is higher, the permanent driver is cheaper in year one.
If the agency total is lower, look at the quiet months. A fleet that books no agency drivers from January to March may be better served by a permanent hire for the core runs and agency for the peaks only.
The cash sum leaves something out. A permanent driver learns your routes and your customers, and you can plan the rota weeks ahead.
One risk to price in: a General Employment Permit holder can change employer once nine months have passed since they started their first permit job in Ireland. A driver who leaves at month ten takes your one-off costs with them. Fair pay, decent routes and home time give a driver reasons to stay.
The Wait, and Where the Licence Fits
This is the strongest case for agency cover, so be clear about it. You book an agency driver when you need one. A permit driver comes after a wait. The job has to be advertised for 28 days before you can apply, and DETE needs the application at least 12 weeks before the start date. Then the driver has to get here. Keep agency cover running until the driver's first shift, and count the agency invoices for that wait in your sums.
The licence is a year-two condition, not a day-one block. DETE's HGV drivers page says the first permit, for up to two years, can be granted on a valid CE or C1E licence or a mutually recognised equivalent. At renewal, DETE needs an Irish CE/C1E licence. Citizens Information says a driver who becomes normally resident in Ireland should exchange their licence or begin applying for an Irish one. Our advice: start the exchange soon after the driver arrives, so it is not a problem in month twenty.
Which licences DETE accepts in the first place, and from which countries, is set out in our HGV driver guide. Check that before anything else.
The 50:50 Rule in a Small Fleet
When you apply, at least half your employees must be nationals of the EEA (the EU countries plus Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway), Switzerland or the UK. DETE counts every employee in the business, not just the drivers, so your yard, warehouse and office staff all count.
That matters most in a small haulage firm. A fleet that already sponsors several drivers can reach the limit with seats still empty. Count your employees before you plan to replace all your agency cover with permit hires. Our guide to the 50:50 rule explains the count.
How CA Recruitment Helps
Send us a year of agency driver invoices and tell us which seats they covered. We will compare the year for you and say plainly if agency cover is still the cheaper answer for some of them. Where a permanent hire makes sense, we source drivers with a qualifying licence and manage the permit from the advert to arrival. See our logistics and warehousing recruitment page, or book a free consultation.
Frequently asked questions
It depends on how often you book. Agency cover has no upfront cost and you pay only for the days you book, so it suits holiday cover and short peaks. By law an agency driver must get equal treatment on pay with a driver you hire directly. For a seat you fill with agency most weeks of the year, compare twelve months of agency invoices for that seat with a year of permanent payroll plus the one-off hiring costs.
€36,605 a year, the standard General Employment Permit minimum. DETE works out the hourly equivalent over a 39-hour week, which comes to about €18.05 an hour. Only basic salary and health insurance payments count towards it. Our advice: pay the floor in basic salary and treat overtime and night-out money as extra.
The first permit, for up to two years, can be granted on a valid CE or C1E licence or a mutually recognised equivalent, so the Irish licence is not a condition of starting. DETE needs an Irish CE/C1E licence at renewal, and Citizens Information says a driver who becomes normally resident in Ireland should exchange their licence or begin applying for an Irish one. Our advice: start the exchange soon after arrival.
Not quickly. The job has to be advertised for 28 days before you can apply, DETE needs the application at least 12 weeks before the start date, and the driver then has to get here. Keep agency cover running until the driver's first shift.
No. Section 55 of the Employment Permits Act 2024 bars an employer from deducting permit, recruitment or travel costs it paid from the permit holder's pay, or recovering them any other way.